Private by designWe never tie what you check to who you are. No ad trackers. We never sell data.What we measureYour controls
Once Again · Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Salted - 9 lbs
Code ••• 2399onceagain.com
This check is based on this exact product page. Wrong product?Public sources checked today·onceagain.com·a person reviewed it today·next check in about 16 days (sooner for the medical claims)
Check complete · analyst-reviewedNo exact-product confirmation today
4 badge types assessed. 3 have independent evidence at a wider scope (the brand, the product line, or a certified supplier), not this exact item; 1 is a self-declared claim that needs no certificate.
- Gluten-FreeIndependent support — brand or product line
Matters if you avoid gluten. If it is a medical need (celiac disease), also check the current package.
- OrganicIndependent support — brand or product line
A defined production standard. See which certifier confirmed it and what it covers.
- VeganSeller states this — nothing found that contradicts it
Matters if you avoid all animal-derived ingredients.
- Non-GMOIndependent support — brand or product line
A sourcing choice about how ingredients are grown, not a proven health or safety advantage.
5 of 10 claims on this product page were checked here. Not yet assessed: Kosher, Keto, Made in USA, High protein, No preservatives / No artificial additives. See the full list.
Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Salted - 9 lbs: full evidence for each claim below
Paying TilliT changes how fast a check is reviewed and how much help a merchant gets — it never changes a result. Only new evidence does. This assessment ran the identical automated methodology whether or not this merchant has ever worked with TilliT.
Claims we checked
Status as assessed Nov 12, 2026. This link always opens the latest result.
Every claim we saw on this page
Everything the product page claims — including claims TilliT does not verify. TilliT assesses six badge types; anything else is listed here so you can see the full picture and check it yourself.
Assessed by TilliT4 badge types, covering 5 statements
TilliT ran a full public-evidence check on this claim — see the badge-by-badge section above for what it found.
Organic
See the Organic result above.
Vegan
See the Vegan result above.
Non-GMO
See the Non-GMO result above.
Gluten-Free
See the Gluten-Free result above.
Not yet checked by TilliT2 claims
This is a real certification or claim type, but TilliT doesn't verify it yet. It is shown here so you know the product makes the claim — not as a judgement either way. Check it yourself using the note next to each one.
- What is this?
Kosher
On the page: “BLANCHED PLEASE RECYCLE PLASTIC TUBS . KOSHER SELL BY : PEANUT ALLERGEN ORGAR EMPLOYEE”
What it means: A kosher-certifying agency has reviewed the product against Jewish dietary law, usually with on-site rabbinical supervision.
Why TilliT doesn't verify it: Kosher certification is granted by independent agencies (OU, OK, Star-K, KOF-K and others). TilliT doesn't verify the kosher claim itself. (It does read the Orthodox Union's product data on some checks, but only as an indirect signal for a dairy-free claim — never to confirm kosher status.)
How to check it yourself: Look for the certifying agency's symbol on the package (a letter mark such as OU, OK, Star-K or KOF-K), then search that agency's online product database for the brand.
- What is this?
Keto
On the page: “Gluten Free Certified IN Vegan Kosher Keto Plant - Based TRADE Protein Refrigeration”
What it means: The product is presented as suitable for a ketogenic (very low carbohydrate) diet.
Why TilliT doesn't verify it: Most "keto" wording is a self-declared description of the nutrition profile. There is a third-party "Keto Certified" program (Paleo Foundation), but TilliT doesn't check its register yet.
How to check it yourself: Check the carbohydrate figure on the Nutrition Facts panel. If the package shows a "Keto Certified" mark, look the brand up on the Paleo Foundation site.
Outside TilliT's checks3 claims
These are marketing or nutrition-label descriptions rather than independently certified claims, so they aren't something TilliT verifies.
- What is this?
Made in USA
On the page: “CERTIFIED ORGANIC BY OREGON TILTH PRODUCT OF USA NON GMO Project VERIFIED nongmoproject”
What it means: An origin claim about where the product was made or grown.
Why TilliT doesn't verify it: "Made in USA" is regulated by the FTC as an on-label claim, not a third-party certification, so it's outside TilliT's checks.
How to check it yourself: There's no public register; this relies on the manufacturer's own records.
- What is this?
High protein
On the page: “Plant-based diet • Gluten-free diet • High protein diet • Vegan and vegetarians • Mediterranean”
What it means: A nutrition-content claim about protein.
Why TilliT doesn't verify it: Nutrient-content claims are regulated on the label by the FDA, not certified by a third party.
How to check it yourself: Check the protein grams and %DV on the Nutrition Facts panel.
- What is this?
No preservatives / No artificial additives
On the page: “our products. Sustainable Production No Preservatives Ethically Sourced No Hydrogenated”
What it means: A claim about what the product does not contain.
Why TilliT doesn't verify it: "No preservatives / additives" claims are label claims regulated by the FDA, not third-party certified.
How to check it yourself: Read the full ingredient list.
TilliT also looked for allergen-free, fair trade claims. None appear on this product's page, so there was nothing to verify.
Shopping for more than one person?
Add family profiles (opens in a new tab) to see which claims matter to whom on this result.
Supply chain & sourcing
Who makes and moves this product, and where it comes from, from public sources only. It's background context, not evidence for or against any badge claim.
- The seller's own informationProduct page labelling text
The product page describes how it is made: "roasting". This describes the production process; it does not name the business that makes the product. Manufacturer not established from the public information checked.
“About Our Process Made by roasting and grinding blanched, dry roasted peanuts until they are wonderfully creamy.”
What this means: This is the seller's own statement about where the product comes from. It is useful context, but it has not been independently checked.
Open source - The seller's own informationProduct page labelling text
The product's own labelling states a country of origin of 'USA NON GMO Project VERIFIED no'. Origin statements are regulated on-label claims, not third-party certifications.
“ASSURANCE TECHNICIAN ONCE AGAIN NUT BUTTER COLLECTIVE , NUNDA , NY 14517-0429 ( 888 ) 800-8075 CERTIFIED ORGANIC BY OREGON TILTH PRODUCT OF USA NON GMO Project VERIFIED nongmoproject.org GF HONEST GLUTEN FREE Gluten Free Certified IN Vegan Kosher Keto Plant - Based TRADE Protein Refrigeration not…”
What this means: This is the seller's own statement about where the product comes from. It is useful context, but it has not been independently checked.
Open source - The seller's own informationProduct labelling (packaging image)
The product's own labelling states a country of origin of 'USA NON GMO Project VERIFIED no'. Origin statements are regulated on-label claims, not third-party certifications.
“ASSURANCE TECHNICIAN ONCE AGAIN NUT BUTTER COLLECTIVE , NUNDA , NY 14517-0429 ( 888 ) 800-8075 CERTIFIED ORGANIC BY OREGON TILTH PRODUCT OF USA NON GMO Project VERIFIED nongmoproject.org GF HONEST GLUTEN FREE Gluten Free Certified IN Vegan Kosher Keto Plant - Based TRADE Protein Refrigeration not…”
What this means: This is the seller's own statement about where the product comes from. It is useful context, but it has not been independently checked.
Open source - The seller's own informationBrand sourcing / ingredients page
The brand publishes a page about its own suppliers / sourcing. This is the company's own account of its supply chain — worth reading, but not an independently verified supplier list.
What this means: This is the seller's own statement about where the product comes from. It is useful context, but it has not been independently checked.
Open source - Government-hosted recordUK Food Hygiene Rating Scheme (FSA)
A UK Food Hygiene Rating Scheme inspection for a business named 'Once Upon Again' in Worthing recorded a rating of 4/5 on 2025-07-31.
What this means: A UK food-safety inspection rating for premises tied to this brand. It reflects kitchen and food-handling hygiene, not whether the product is organic, gluten-free or anything else a badge covers.
Open source - Government-hosted recordEPA ECHO (facility compliance history)
US EPA facilities whose registered name matches 'Once Again Nut Butter' have 2 record(s) in the EPA's Enforcement and Compliance History Online (ECHO) database, including 0 inspection(s).
What this means: The manufacturer's facilities show up in the US EPA's environmental compliance database by name, but have no inspections on record there. This is general company background and does not bear on any badge claim.
Open source
Does this apply to the exact batch or lot you're buying?
Batch-level coverage cannot be inferred from public product page claims.
- Active batch mapping requires merchant-provided data via TilliT verification.
Assessed Nov 12, 2026 · updated Nov 12, 2026 · last reviewed by a TilliT analyst Nov 12, 2026
TilliT plans to re-check this product on or after Nov 28, 2026.
Methodology version 2026.10.4.
Produced by build a44a20039aa1 · ingredient reader 2026.10.14-1 · decision rules 2026.10.23-1 · explanation templates 2026.10.23-1.