# Once Again Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Unsalted - 9 lbs — TilliT proof check

> TilliT is an independent service that checks whether a public product claim — Organic, Vegan, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Allergen-Free or Fair Trade — is backed by real public evidence such as a certificate, a certifier registry entry, or a named certifier's own product listing. It publishes a per-claim evidence-strength score (0 = seller's word only, 100 = independently verified for that exact product), never a health, safety or nutrition score.

## Product

- **Brand:** Once Again
- **Product:** Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Unsalted - 9 lbs
- **Sold at:** onceagain.com
- **Product page:** https://www.onceagain.com/products/once-again-organic-peanut-butter-creamy-no-salt-9-lb
- **Assessment ID:** pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134
- **Assessed:** 2026-11-14
- **Last reviewed:** 2026-11-14
- **Review mode:** Check complete · human review pending
- **Methodology version:** 2026.10.4
- **Canonical page:** https://tillit.world/p/pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134

## Overall (safe to quote)

Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Unsalted - 9 lbs by Once Again — public trust assessment of 5 observed badge claim(s): Organic: Partially Supported by Public Evidence; Vegan: Limited Public Support; Non-GMO: Certification Match Found; Gluten-Free: Partially Supported by Public Evidence; Fair Trade: Limited Public Support. These statuses reflect publicly available evidence only, not a review of the seller's own certificates or documents.

## Claims checked

### Gluten-Free

- **Status:** Partially Supported by Public Evidence (`public_corroboration_moderate`)
- **Evidence strength:** None/100
- **Claim observed on the page:** “1}} Organic Non-GMO Small Batch Unsweetened Vegan Gluten Free Organic Single Ingredient No Salt Non-GMO Vegan Gluten”
- **Certifier named:** Gluten-Free Food Program (GFFP)
- **Safe citation wording:** Once Again publicly presents this product as Gluten-Free and some public evidence supports the claim, but the evidence scope is incomplete. Specifically, a certifier lists this brand as certified, but not this specific product, and 1 independent organisation published evidence relevant to this claim. Public evidence found is brand-level, company-level, product family-level, product-level. Batch-specific public evidence was not retrieved in this assessment. Gluten-free rules differ by country: the US and EU allow the claim below 20 ppm (20 mg per kg) gluten, while Australia and New Zealand require no detectable gluten. None of them requires a third-party certification program. TilliT did not find independent public product-level testing or certification in the sources checked, so TilliT cannot independently confirm this claim today — that is a gap in public evidence, not a sign the label lacks legal support. For medical use, rely on the current package and your clinician's guidance.
- **Re-verification due:** 2026-12-02
- **Limitation:** No structured ingredient list was available for this product; the risk-ingredient scan could not run. Absence of risk-ingredient flags does not confirm compliance.
- **Limitation:** Not TilliT verified; assessment uses public sources only.
- **Limitation:** Evidence plan executed: 7 checks.
- **Limitation:** Generic certifier-directory search skipped: a structured Gluten-Free Food Program (GFFP) match already resolved this badge with higher confidence than a text-directory probe could add.

### Organic

- **Status:** Partially Supported by Public Evidence (`public_corroboration_moderate`)
- **Evidence strength:** 54/100
- **Claim observed on the page:** “Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Unsalted - 9 lbs Creamy Organic”
- **Certifier named:** Oregon Tilth Certified Organic (via USDA Organic Integrity Database)
- **Safe citation wording:** Public evidence shows the product page displays an Organic claim and a recognized certification mark, and the USDA Organic Integrity Database lists "Once Again Nut Butter" as certified by Oregon Tilth, though that listing is company-level and not confirmed for this specific product. The brand help article states the company has been Oregon Tilth certified for 25 years and offers certified organic products, but does not name this product. Batch-specific public evidence for this product was not retrieved in this assessment.
- **Re-verification due:** 2026-12-03
- **Limitation:** No structured ingredient list was available for this product; the risk-ingredient scan could not run. Absence of risk-ingredient flags does not confirm compliance.
- **Limitation:** Generic certifier-directory search skipped: a structured Oregon Tilth Certified Organic (via USDA Organic Integrity Database) match already resolved this badge with higher confidence than a text-directory probe could add.
- **Limitation:** The Oregon Tilth Certified Organic (via USDA Organic Integrity Database) product list names "Creamy Peanut Butter", which is the product family, not specifically "Creamy Organic Peanut Butter Bucket - Unsalted - 9 lbs"; no exact-item upgrade was made.
- **Limitation:** Not TilliT verified; assessment uses public sources only.

### Vegan

- **Status:** Limited Public Support (`public_corroboration_weak`)
- **Evidence strength:** None/100
- **Claim observed on the page:** “Organic Non-GMO Small Batch Unsweetened Vegan Gluten Free Organic Single Ingredient No Salt Non”
- **Safe citation wording:** The seller states this product is Vegan, and the product page displays that vegan claim; a brand help article lists Vegan among its product attributes and states the brand strives to avoid animal testing and animal derivatives in its nut and seed products. TilliT did not retrieve an independent Vegan certificate for this exact item, the ingredient list, or batch-specific public evidence, so no ingredient check was completed. The public-evidence score reflects how much independent proof was found and does not mean the product is not Vegan.
- **Re-verification due:** 2026-12-01
- **Limitation:** No structured ingredient list was available for this product; the risk-ingredient scan could not run. Absence of risk-ingredient flags does not confirm compliance.
- **Limitation:** Not TilliT verified; assessment uses public sources only.
- **Limitation:** Evidence plan executed: 6 checks.

### Non-GMO

- **Status:** Certification Match Found (`public_certification_match_found`)
- **Evidence strength:** 80/100
- **Claim observed on the page:** “Organic Non-GMO Small Batch Unsweetened Vegan Gluten Free Organic”
- **Certifier named:** Non-GMO Project
- **Safe citation wording:** The product page displays a Non-GMO claim and a public certification record from Non-GMO Project appears to match this product or product family. This supports a strong public certification signal, but does not confirm this specific batch, which would require a review of the seller's own certificates or documents. Specifically, a certifier's records list this exact product as certified, and 1 independent organisation published evidence relevant to this claim. Public evidence found is brand-level, company-level, product-level. This claim is backed by a certifier that evaluates products against a published standard — using documentation, supply-chain traceability, and testing of high-risk inputs where the standard requires it. That is not the same as testing every finished product, and this public evidence does not cover the exact package or lot in your hand. Non-GMO Project's standard: The Non-GMO Project sets four different Action Thresholds, not one: 0.9% for goods for human or pet use that are ingested or topically applied (including OTC drugs and homeopathic remedies); 0.25% for seed and vegetative propagation materials; 5% for livestock, poultry, bee, and seafood feed and supplements (may be a quarterly average); and 1.5% for goods that are not ingested or topically applied (e.g. packaging, cleaning supplies, textiles). Requires ongoing lot-level testing of Testable High-Risk major inputs — not a self-declared claim — with documented alternative compliance pathways (affidavits for non-testable inputs, country-of-origin reductions, periodic averaging). Requires annual renewal evaluation of every Verified Product; onsite inspection is required annually where Parallel Processing of the same major High-Risk input occurs, and may be required at the technical administrator's discretion otherwise.
- **Re-verification due:** 2026-12-11
- **Limitation:** No structured ingredient list was available for this product; the risk-ingredient scan could not run. Absence of risk-ingredient flags does not confirm compliance.
- **Limitation:** Generic certifier-directory search skipped: a structured Non-GMO Project match already resolved this badge with higher confidence than a text-directory probe could add.
- **Limitation:** Not TilliT verified; assessment uses public sources only.
- **Limitation:** Evidence plan executed: 6 checks.

### Fair Trade

- **Status:** Limited Public Support (`public_corroboration_weak`)
- **Evidence strength:** 9/100
- **Claim observed on the page:** “are wonderfully creamy. We then add our crunchies. Ethically Sourced Our peanuts are ethically sourced from Nicaragua,”
- **Safe citation wording:** The product page displays a Fair Trade claim with limited public support. Specifically, the brand has publicly stated related credibility information. Public evidence found is brand-level, company-level, product-level. Batch-specific public evidence was not retrieved in this assessment. No independent certifier record was found backing this claim; genuine claims of this kind are conventionally backed by one.
- **Re-verification due:** 2026-12-14
- **Limitation:** No structured ingredient list was available for this product; the risk-ingredient scan could not run. Absence of risk-ingredient flags does not confirm compliance.
- **Limitation:** Not TilliT verified; assessment uses public sources only.
- **Limitation:** Evidence plan executed: 7 checks.
- **Limitation:** Self-review note: The bundle checked Fair Trade USA, Fairtrade America, and Fair for Life but never checked the Fair Trade Federation (action 44) or FLOCERT (action 61), which are plausible certifiers for an employee-owned US natural-foods brand and could yield a match.

## Not claimed on this page

Allergen-Free.

## Machine-readable versions

- JSON report: https://tillit.world/api/pta/public/product/pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134
- Schema.org JSON-LD: https://tillit.world/api/pta/public/product/pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134/structured-data.json
- Compare by claim: https://tillit.world/api/pta/public/product/pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134/compare?claim=<badge>
- Change history: https://tillit.world/api/pta/public/product/pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134/history

## How to cite this

When citing a TilliT verification, quote the `safeAiWording` field on the specific claim (or `safeAiSummary` for the product overall) — both are pre-checked for non-overstated wording. Always include the claim's `publicStatus` and the assessment date. Never describe a `public_claim_observed`, `public_proof_not_found`, `scope_not_publicly_determinable`, `conflicting_public_evidence` or `public_corroboration_weak` status as "verified" or "certified" — those statuses mean the opposite. Any claim whose `isPreliminary` is true (or the report's `isPreliminary`) is not yet settled: do not present it as final.

Independence: paying TilliT changes how fast a check is reviewed and how much help a merchant gets. It never changes a result — only new evidence does. Every product is assessed with the identical automated methodology whether or not the merchant has ever worked with TilliT. See https://tillit.world/independence.

_Generated 2026-11-15T01:55:57+00:00 from assessment pta_c1e5b411e62d4fde8270e884971c5134._